
Undy
116183
3026
33

So here's a normal eye

And here's an image this eye sees.

Now here's an eye that has half of the pupul obstructed.

Would that eye see the image like this?

No. The image would instead appear like this - nothing is obstructed, the image is just darker because less light enters the eye.

Now the reason why that happens is to do with how lenses work - basically every part of a lens is capable of forming the whole image. The size of the lens matters only to enable more or less total amount of light to be transported (brighter or darker image).

Here you can see that even with half of the lens obstructed, the whole image is still formed, just with half as many light rays.

However the shape of the opening has an effect on the image - but only on the unfocused parts of it. Here's a modified photography lens with a heart cutout in front.

The image taken with such a lens - as you can see the parts of the image that are in focus are unaffected, but the bright lights in the background have taken the shape of hearts. That's how bokeh works.

Here's a hexagonal aperture of a photography lens.

The bokeh in a photo taken by such a lens would also take a hexagonal shape like in this image.

But there's also another place where you can see that effect - lens flares. Here every secondary flare is also a hexagon. But there's another effect going on - there are 6 distinct spikes around the sun - those are formed by diffraction of light along the straight edges of the hexagonal aperture. If the aperture was an octagon, there would be 8 spikes etc.

You can also see that effect in the Hubble Space Telescope images - here every bright star has a four way cross around it.

This is because Hubble, like most Newtonian telescopes has a secondary mirror in front of the primary mirror - it's suspended in the middle of the telescope by four thin beams that are forming the cross pattern. The light entering the telescope diffracts along the edges of the beams and forms those cross flares around bright stars.

Evi1Gav
For the human eye, it's worse, because the brain also makes shit up. It's why it's difficult to know when there's minor damage.
Heeeyyoooo
That's pretty fucking neat
wavinggrass
kEMup
Boksha
As a physics MSc, by the fourth image, I was ready to get quite angry. Upvote for the excellent explanation.
Undy
Thanks! The explanation, especially the lens diagram is very simplified but I hope it gets the point across :P
Hanska01
Thank you for sharing your expertise and knowledge :)
danielsjack4227
This post has both depth and perception. No lack of vision found.
Rayj420
It also has an OPTICAL illusion. But seriously, go to the picture with the black heart and scroll up and down and see what happens
Ricedcrisper
Poked myself in the eye trying this out. Worth it.
EladMan
I want to live where this eye sees.
thegarthok
williamoftheoak
As an optical engineer, I approve of this message.
buzzl1ght
People who suffer from hemianopia have vision like #4 usually cause by damage to the optic nerve. From stroke, tumor or other trauma
TocinoATX
superuncreative
Let me summarize this for everyone. Science. Science is how lenses work.
Undy
Yeah, but it's exactly "explanations" like these that cause so many people nowadays to be scientifically illiterate.
Aaronb1138
Nobody show the aperture shape effects to Michael Bay or JJ Abrams. We'll fucking cut you.
katanatripsis
Yes, but I want you to imagine Michael Bay using heart bokeh in his explosions.
tanneberger2
What an eye-opener
zyxzevn
Bokeh fun. Hearts, ufos, rings. Can also be created in so many ways, also with telescopes.
ExistentialDreadlocks
DemonOtter
Thanks for bringing this into focus
Bunuslippur
TheRealGeorgeMcfly
This post makes me see things differently
CrystalShipsCometh
charmandeur
baronz3r
YeeticusOfTheTribeYeet
MoonBeast64
GroumphLePreux
*autofocus.
Diyamin
Homemade bokeh lense mods are so fun to mess around with
Onerrorresumenext
Eye liked this post.
nosebleedcremebrulee
pupul
Jonavilez
I always wondered why pictures had these effects. Thanks!
Ifekinlovesauerkraut
I just wish that game devs would stop implementing imperfections like chromatic aberration and lens flares into their games.
Boksha
I think one of the problems is game developers don't go outside during the day.
Undy
I also do 3D graphics, and I can tell you that using reference is almost mandatory. It's usually the art directors that fuk these things up.
Ifekinlovesauerkraut
This. Many art directors have some movie background and they really believe that games want those effects.
Undy
Yes! The only time lens flares (and dirt) make sense is when the character is wearing a helmet, googles etc.
Blizky
Life imitates art and it’s artifacts
DracoSicarius
If you have larger than average eyes, does that mean everything appears brighter to you?
DracoSicarius
Also could that be a cause for photic sneeze reflex?
TeppeMannen
Pk, cool, but... am I the only one who saw the heart on the lense bounce like a motherfucker when scrolling?
Undy
That's probably because your monitor is an IPS panel - they can have artifacts like these.
Undy
Damn, you guys are relentless with these puns :P
circlebreaker
As is tradition.
LlamaFrequency
It's reflective of the nature of the average imagur user
HsuDoNihm
And to some extent of how interesting we found the material.
Undy
Yeah, not an imgur regular but I certainly noticed a pattern with the comments under my posts :P
hectomet
Your theory is not solid, simple explanation is cover the half of your camera lens and see what happens.
Undy
That really depends on the lens - photographic lenses are complicated, they have multiple glass elements making them behave differently...
Undy
than a single glass lens. For some lenses covering half would only cut the light by 50%, and for some it would obstruct the image.
Undy
My zoom lens for example is the latter. Some fast prime lenses on the other hand are the former. My telescope also behaves like the former.
StanAgde
Isnt the image inverted until the brain translates it into the correct orentation
Undy
Yep!
VVulf
The brain adapts to changes quite quickly. https://www.theguardian.com/education/2012/nov/12/improbable-research-seeing-upside-down
NZerow
Very interesting. Are you able to help me understand why during an eclipse, a circular hole produces a light shape similar to the eclipse?
Undy
Small holes work similarly to how lenses work. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camera_obscura
Undy
In fact that's how eyes evolved - they had pinholes instead of lenses, in fact some worms still have these 'unevolved' eyes.
Undy
As you can see pinholes can also form an image - they have a downside - they let through way less light.