In this case, it shouldn't matter, I'd say. It's a cartoonish character and it's normal to not look proportional, and its body to not be anatomically correct. I mean, if you're going to pick on this, you might want to mention that his arms are orangutan-sized, and his neck can't possibly support his head.
That's what immediately stuck out to me on a primal level. If you'd read OP's response, it's clearly something they've thought about as well. Anyway, I'm glad nothing bothers you because in cartoons nothing matters ever.
Yeah, I played with that a lot. The way it is drawn you want the shoulder to be behind, but the arm in front. Im going to have to use some tricks to get this better.
TruckStopRats
The tan lines are really doing something for me, and it's not what you'd think..
JackHL01
is he eating spinach though?
PapaUbu
I still preferred A
MattyMatter
Yeah I hear ya. I liked A too, but i thought it just didnt give me as many options for animating and giving the character a personality.
BenderRodriguezz
Pretty cool! I'm sure you already noticed, since this is just a test animation, but his upper arms should cross in front of his body, not behind it.
irisewithredeyes
In this case, it shouldn't matter, I'd say. It's a cartoonish character and it's normal to not look proportional, and its body to not be anatomically correct. I mean, if you're going to pick on this, you might want to mention that his arms are orangutan-sized, and his neck can't possibly support his head.
BenderRodriguezz
That's what immediately stuck out to me on a primal level. If you'd read OP's response, it's clearly something they've thought about as well. Anyway, I'm glad nothing bothers you because in cartoons nothing matters ever.
MattyMatter
Yeah, I played with that a lot. The way it is drawn you want the shoulder to be behind, but the arm in front. Im going to have to use some tricks to get this better.
BenderRodriguezz
I was thinking about that, and maybe there's a way to make the torso lines at his shoulders sort of shrink or disappear as his arms cross over?